• Taking a probiotic wrong?

I cut open an encapsulated 25 billion cfu 12 strain probiotic that's normally meant to open in the large intestine. I put in a cup of water and drank it. Ever since then I've been burping a lot, gassy. crazy noises from my intestines, stomach pain/intestinal pain, acne, changes in stool/constipation. The probiotic had many different strains of Bifidobacterium and lactobacillus and 1 strain of streptococcus thermophilus. It seems some of these strains colonized in my small intestine that aren't supposed to be there. Is there a way to reduce the numbers or kill these otherwise good bacteria if in the large intestine that is overpopulating my small intestine now with an antibiotic or herbal antibiotic? Maybe a certain strain I can introduce will push out the ones that aren't supposed to be there?

5 Answers

  • Naturopathic Physician
  • Bend, Oregon

Your symptomsburping, gas, intestinal noises, pain, acne, and changes in bowel habitscould suggest that the highpotency probiotic you consumed may have disrupted the balance of your gut microbiome, potentially contributing to an overgrowth of bacteria in the small intestine, a condition sometimes referred to as Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth SIBO. Cutting open the capsule and consuming the probiotic in water may have allowed the bacteria to activate earlier in the digestive tract e.g., the stomach or small intestine rather than reaching the large intestine, where they are typically designed to release. Here are some steps and considerations to address your symptoms and restore gut balance Pause Probiotic Use Temporarily To avoid further aggravating the issue, I recommend stopping the probiotic for now. This will give your gut a chance to stabilize while we address the overgrowth. Support Digestive Health Dietary Adjustments Focus on a lowFODMAP diet for 24 weeks to reduce fermentable carbohydrates that feed bacterial overgrowth. Include easily digestible foods like bone broth, cooked vegetables e.g., zucchini, carrots, and lean proteins. Avoid sugars, starches, and processed foods, as these can exacerbate symptoms. Hydration Drink plenty of water to support digestion and bowel regularity. Herbal teas like peppermint or ginger can help soothe the gut. Herbal Antimicrobials To reduce potential bacterial overgrowth in the small intestine, herbal antimicrobials can be effective and gentler than pharmaceutical antibiotics. Options include Berberine Known for its antimicrobial properties, it can help reduce bacterial populations in the small intestine. Oregano Oil A potent antimicrobial, Garlic Allicin A natural antibacterial, taken as a supplement Note Always take these under the guidance of an experienced practitioner, as they can be potent. Avoid Pharmaceutical Antibiotics Unless Necessary Antibiotics like rifaximin are sometimes used for SIBO, but they can disrupt the gut microbiome further and should be a last resort. Herbal options are often effective and better tolerated. If symptoms persist, you can consider testing for SIBO e.g., a breath test to confirm the diagnosis. Rebalancing the Microbiome Introducing specific probiotic strains to crowd out the overpopulated bacteria is not typically recommended during active symptoms of overgrowth, as it may worsen the issue. Once symptoms improve, you can consider reintroducing a lowdose, singlestrain probiotic e.g., Lactobacillus rhamnosus or Bifidobacterium longum designed for small intestine health, but this should be done cautiously and gradually. Address Acne and Constipation Acne This may be linked to gut inflammation or dysbiosis. Supporting liver detoxification with herbs like milk thistle and increasing fiber e.g., ground flaxseed, 12 tbsp daily may help. Constipation Ensure adequate hydration and consider gentle natural aids like magnesium citrate to promote bowel regularity. Next Steps I recommend scheduling a consultation with an experienced practitioner to discuss your symptoms in detail, review your health history, and tailor a plan. You should also consider functional testing e.g., SIBO breath test or stool analysis to pinpoint the issue. In the meantime, start with the dietary changes and stop the probiotic and schedule an appointment with an experienced practitioner with a speciality in GI health and SIBO treatment. Always check in with your provider before starting any new supplements, especially if youre on medications or have other health conditions. I hope the above information is helpful and I wish you the best of luck in your health journey. In good health, Dr. Natasha Rudd

  • Naturopath
  • Naples, FL

If you already have digestive issues, an overgrowth of bad bacteria, or SIBO before taking a probiotic, it can trigger the symptoms you're experiencing. Essentially, you've created a situation where beneficial and harmful bacteria are competing for space, leading to bloating, gas, burping, and stool changes. In my experience, it's best to optimize digestion first before introducing probiotics to prevent bacterial imbalances. Heres how you can support your gut: 1. Start with D-Limonene Taking d-limonene every other day away from food can help improve digestion by supporting stomach acid production, reducing reflux, and breaking down biofilms that harbor bad bacteria. 2. Use Bee Propolis A capsule of bee propolis daily can assist with targeting harmful bacteria while maintaining gut balance. Its antimicrobial properties may help suppress unwanted bacterial overgrowth. 3. Support Bile Flow Many gut issues stem from poor bile secretion. Consider adding ox bile, bitter herbs, or milk thistle to ensure optimal fat digestion and bacterial regulation. 4. Reduce Fermentable Foods Temporarily If symptoms persist, limiting prebiotics inulin, FOS and high-fiber foods may help reduce excessive fermentation in the small intestine. 5. Introduce Probiotics Strategically If you decide to retry probiotics later, starting with soil-based strains or Saccharomyces boulardii may help balance gut flora without overwhelming your system. By addressing digestion first, you'll likely experience better results when reintroducing probiotics. Have you noticed certain foods or supplements worsening symptoms? If so, tracking patterns might give you further insights.

  • Integrative Medicine | Integrative Medicine
  • Arlington, TX

Those probiotics are designed in that way to pass through the stomach intact and then deploy in the bowels. If you cut it open before you drink it You have defeated the purpose. Also it seems you may need a proper integrative or functional doctors consult as well as testing your micro biome and gut function to see which strains you need more of and which are overgrown. TEST instead of GUESS. There are natural antibiotics that can help You get your gut back in balance but it is best to get advice from a professional. Fennel seeds and caraway seeds when chewed are great for breaking up gas , but dont take more than 3-7 At a time. You may also need food allergy or intolerance testing. Again,its best to work with a professional. Best wishes Dr Shabana Parvez , MD

  • Doctor
  • Kirkland, WA

First of all, wondering why you are cutting the capsule rather than taking it as is. Secondly, most of the bacteria is getting into the stomach and may not be going past it not being in a capsule. If you have an overgrowth of bad bacteria, when you take a probiotic and the good guys are coming in and fighting the bad guys you will have those symptoms such as gas, burping, noises, pain, diarrhea, constipation, etc. I would recommend taking it as it is meant to be, in the capsule and not opening it up. This will help it get to the place it is meant to be. You don't want to kill any of the good bacteria and the only way to do so would be an antibiotic. Otherwise, just don't take the probiotic and the good bacteria will eventually die off with stress and other causes, however, I do not advise doing so. To attract what should be there, you should take probiotics and feed your good bacteria and make them stronger. That will also help them fight the bad bacteria.

  • Gastroenterologist
  • LAS VEGAS, NV

It is very unlikely that taking a probiotic caused bacterial overgrowth of the small intestine (SIBO), even if you drank the probiotic. There is a breath test that can help diagnose SIBO though it is not a perfect test to say the least. There are other possible explanations for your symptoms, including carbohydrate malabsorption. Since the problems have been going on for weeks then you should get evaluated by a GI physician who can get a full history and determine if any testing is needed.

Copyrights © 2021 by TODAY'S NURSE. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy